# Grace in Leadership

**Church:** Haven of Rest Bible Church  
**Speaker:** Pastor David Spivey  
**Date:** January 25, 2026 • AM Service  
**Primary Scriptures:** Titus 1:5–14; 1 Timothy 4:12; 2 Timothy 2:1–4, 15, 24–25; 3:16–17; 4:1–8  
**Supporting Scriptures:** Titus 2:11–14; 2 Corinthians 11:23–28; 12:9; Ephesians 5:25; Colossians 2:16–17; 2 Timothy 4:10–21; 1 Timothy 5:17, 19; Matthew 20:25–28; Hebrews 11:4

---

## 1. Core Message Summary

The transforming grace of God that saves and entirely sanctifies believers also raises up holy, accountable spiritual leaders—elders who govern local churches not as worldly bosses, but as living specimens, faithful soldiers, diligent scholars, gentle servants, and caring shepherds. Every believer—young and old—must understand, pray for, and step into this biblical standard of grace-empowered character so the church shines with Christlikeness and finishes well.

### Primary Scripture Texts (KJV)

> **Titus 1:5–14** — For this cause left I thee in Crete, that thou shouldest set in order the things that are wanting, and ordain elders in every city, as I had appointed thee: If any be blameless, the husband of one wife, having faithful children not accused of riot or unruly. For a bishop must be blameless, as the steward of God; not selfwilled, not soon angry, not given to wine, no striker, not given to filthy lucre; But a lover of hospitality, a lover of good men, sober, just, holy, temperate; Holding fast the faithful word as he hath been taught, that he may be able by sound doctrine both to exhort and to convince the gainsayers. For there are many unruly and vain talkers and deceivers, specially they of the circumcision: Whose mouths must be stopped, who subvert whole houses, teaching things which they ought not, for filthy lucre's sake. One of themselves, even a prophet of their own, said, The Cretians are alway liars, evil beasts, slow bellies. This witness is true. Wherefore rebuke them sharply, that they may be sound in the faith; Not giving heed to Jewish fables, and commandments of men, that turn from the truth.
>
> **1 Timothy 4:12** — Let no man despise thy youth; but be thou an example of the believers, in word, in conversation, in charity, in spirit, in faith, in purity.
>
> **2 Timothy 2:1–3, 15** — Thou therefore, my son, be strong in the grace that is in Christ Jesus. And the things that thou hast heard of me among many witnesses, the same commit thou to faithful men, who shall be able to teach others also. Thou therefore endure hardness, as a good soldier of Jesus Christ. ... Study to shew thyself approved unto God, a workman that needeth not to be ashamed, rightly dividing the word of truth.
>
> **2 Timothy 4:6–8** — For I am now ready to be offered, and the time of my departure is at hand. I have fought a good fight, I have finished my course, I have kept the faith: Henceforth there is laid up for me a crown of righteousness, which the Lord, the righteous judge, shall give me at that day: and not to me only, but unto all them also that love his appearing.

---

## 2. The Foundation: Transformational Grace on Mission (Titus 2:11–14; 1:1–5)

Before Paul ever tells Titus how to organize churches or appoint leaders, he anchors the entire epistle in the **gospel of grace**. Pastor Spivey opened by reviewing **Titus 2:11–14**. From a Wesleyan-Arminian Conservative Holiness standpoint, Titus 2:11–14 shatters both legalism (trying to earn salvation by human effort) and antinomianism (claiming grace excuses willful sin). Grace has *"appeared to all men"*—universal prevenient grace invites every person everywhere to repent and believe. Yet this grace never leaves a believer unchanged: it is **foundational** (the bedrock of the entire Bible), **transformational** (it trains us to say *no* to ungodliness and worldly lusts and purifies the heart), and **motivational** (it makes us *"zealous of good works"*).

In Titus 1:1, Paul calls himself *"a servant [Greek: doulos, bond-slave] of God"* and sends Titus to **Crete**—a society infamous for lying, lawlessness, laziness, and lust. The Cretans needed conviction leading to transforming grace, and Titus had a demanding mission: *"set in order the things that are wanting, and ordain elders in every city"* (Titus 1:5).

### How the Mission of Grace Shapes Every Believer
- **Grace Reaches Everyone:** Believers carry grace into homes, classrooms, workplaces, and communities—not only to agreeable people, but to the utterly broken, obnoxious, and hostile.
- **Grace Demands Order:** Where new converts are saved out of chaos, the Holy Spirit raises up mature spiritual oversight to *"set in order the things that are wanting"* (Greek: *epidiorthoo*—to straighten out completely).
- **Grace Produces Holy Character:** Christ died to *"redeem us from all iniquity, and purify unto himself a peculiar people"*—a cleansed, Spirit-filled people eager to do good.

> **Holiness Word Study — *Katharizo* & Entire Sanctification (Titus 2:14):**  
> Christ gave Himself to *"purify"* (**katharizo**, to cleanse thoroughly from moral defilement) a people for Himself. In Wesleyan-Arminian theology, salvation begins with justification and new birth and presses onward into **entire sanctification**—a second definite work of grace received by faith and full consecration, in which the Holy Spirit cleanses the heart from inbred carnal self-will and empowers the believer with pure love.

> **In Plain English (For Teens & Young Adults):**  
> Think of grace like an engine, not a hammock. Grace is not a comfy excuse to stay lazy, lie, gossip, or scroll through impure things. Titus 2 says real grace grabs your heart, gives you power to say *no* to sin at school or online, cleans out selfish attitudes inside you, and fires you up to love the hardest people around you.

---

## 3. Guarding the Flock: Biblical Qualifications & Confronting Error (Titus 1:6–14)

Paul lays out non-negotiable moral and doctrinal standards for elders (*presbyteros*) and overseers (*episkopos*), emphasizing godly character and home integrity:
- **Blameless (v. 6–7):** *Anenkletos*—unaccusable; living with such integrity that no legitimate moral scandal can be pinned to the leader's life.
- **Faithful in Marriage and Parenting (v. 6):** A "one-woman man" whose household reflects genuine godly nurture, respect, and order.
- **A Steward of God (v. 7):** *Oikonomos*—a household manager overseeing God's flock, truth, and resources under God's authority.
- **Five Vices Rejected (v. 7):** Not self-willed, not soon angry, not given to wine, no striker, not greedy for filthy lucre.
- **Six Virtues Cultivated (v. 8):** Lover of hospitality, lover of good men, sober, just, holy, and temperate.

Holding fast *"the faithful word as he hath been taught"* (v. 9) equips an elder both to **exhort** believers and to **convince gainsayers**. Because unruly, greedy talkers were subverting entire households with *"Jewish fables"* (extra-biblical rabbinic legends, not the inspired Old Testament) and *"commandments of men,"* Paul commands Titus: *"Whose mouths must be stopped"* and *"rebuke them sharply, that they may be sound in the faith"* (v. 11, 13).

| Biblical Character / Element | Historical Role | Spiritual Type / Picture | Holiness Truth & Application |
| :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- |
| **Apostle Paul** | Bond-slave of Christ & apostle writing the Pastoral Epistles from ministry experience and prison | Seasoned spiritual father and finisher of the race | Grace sustains lifelong fidelity; leaders finish strong by keeping the faith and mentoring others |
| **Titus on Crete** | Paul's trusted delegate left to organize young churches across a corrupt island | Courageous reformer confronting cultural compromise | Grace confronts sin sharply yet redemptively so converts become sound in faith |
| **Timothy at Ephesus** | Younger pastor urged not to let anyone despise his youth | Living specimen (*tupos*) and diligent workman in the Word | Age is no barrier to Spirit-filled maturity in speech, conduct, love, faith, and purity |
| **Gainsayers / Circumcision Party** | Unruly, greedy talkers promoting Jewish fables and human rules in Crete | Carnal intruders corrupting households from the simplicity of Christ | Sound doctrine and firm, loving church discipline are needed to protect vulnerable families |
| **John Mark** | Once deserted Paul's missionary team, mentored by Barnabas, later commended in 2 Tim 4:11 | The restored disciple who became profitable again | Failure is not final when humble repentance meets patient shepherd care |
| **Demas** | Former co-worker who forsook Paul, having loved this present world (2 Tim 4:10) | Tragic warning of apostasy and divided affections | Salvation and endurance require daily faithfulness; loving the world forfeits spiritual usefulness |

> **Wesleyan-Arminian Church Heritage:**  
> Paul deeply treasured the Old Testament Scriptures, yet warned against extra-biblical *"commandments of men"* that obscure the pure gospel. In the Conservative Holiness Movement, biblical standards flow from wholehearted love for God and clear Scriptural principles—never from prideful man-made legalism.

---

## 4. The Office of Elder & Pastor David Spivey's Calling: Biblical Church Structure

In the New Testament, **elder** (*presbyteros*), **bishop/overseer** (*episkopos*), and **pastor/shepherd** (*poimen*) describe the same spiritual office responsible for oversight, doctrinal integrity, and pastoral care.

### Three Models of Church Leadership
1. **Autocratic Pitfall:** A single leader makes unilateral decisions without accountability to fellow elders or the body, risking pride and spiritual abuse.
2. **Democratic Pitfall:** A pastor is treated as a powerless hireling whose teaching and biblical vision are constantly blocked or overridden by popular opinion.
3. **Biblical Plurality:** A Spirit-led head elder leads alongside qualified, mature elders who mutually sharpen one another, answer to the congregation through proper biblical channels (1 Tim 5:19), and ultimately answer to God.

Pastor Spivey traced his own calling: teenage salvation under conviction; a crisis experience of **entire sanctification / Spirit baptism** intensifying his consecration; sensing a call to full-time Christian service around age 14–15; Bible college (returning 1998); teaching at a Christian school in Detroit (2002); teaching youth and adult Sunday school; and receiving clear pastoral confirmation at age 31 in 2006.

> **In Plain English (How God Calls Young People):**  
> You do not have to know your whole 20-year plan at age 15! Stay clean, get sanctified, study your Bible, and say *yes* to the next open door right in front of you.

---

## 5. Role 1 — The Elder as a Specimen of Grace (1 Timothy 4:12)

Paul writes: *"Be thou an example [Greek: **tupos**, a die or pattern] of the believers, in word, in conversation, in charity, in spirit, in faith, in purity."* Pastor Spivey recalled a photo of little Marin holding newborn Macy Grace—because *a picture is worth a thousand words*, the church needs a living picture of grace.

- **Speech and Conduct:** Refusing slander, coarse joking, and petty mudslinging even when attacked.
- **Handling Hardship (2 Cor 12:9):** Proving in trials that God's grace is sufficient.
- **Home and Marriage (Eph 5:25):** Loving his wife sacrificially and raising respectful children introduced to grace.
- **Humility Under Correction:** Hearing honest faults without defensiveness.
- **Heart and Moral Purity (*hagneia*):** Clean thoughts, motives, and relationships when nobody is watching.
- **Outside Reputation:** Respected by unbelievers in finances, conflict, and daily pressures.

> **Holiness Word Study — *Tupos* & *Hagneia*:**  
> Inner heart purity (*hagneia*) and outward godly conduct (*tupos*) belong together. Only a heart cleansed by Jesus' blood and filled with the Holy Spirit can leave a Christlike imprint on the next generation.

---

## 6. Role 2 — The Elder as a Soldier of Grace (2 Timothy 2:1–4)

Paul urges Timothy: *"Be strong [Greek: **endunamoo**, continually empowered] in the grace that is in Christ Jesus... endure hardness, as a good soldier of Jesus Christ."* The real fight is not church politics or family squabbles; it is against **sin, self, and Satan**.

1. **Tough in Trials:** Refusing spiritual wimpiness, an elder endures criticism, financial crises, and accusations on his knees until God refines and steadies him (cf. 2 Cor 11:23–28).
2. **Training Faithful Men:** Following 2 Timothy 2:2, mature leaders invest intentionally in younger men—just as Titus 2 calls older women to mentor younger women.
3. **On Target Always:** Grace is never a "freebie ticket to heaven"; its target is becoming like Jesus Christ for God's glory and others' salvation.

> **In Plain English (Don't Be a Spiritual Wimp):**  
> When someone mocks your faith at school or spreads a rumor, let hard days push you to your knees, avoid drama that pulls you off mission, and encourage one younger believer this week.

---

## 7. Role 3 — The Elder as a Scholar of Grace (2 Timothy 2:15; 3:16–17; 4:13)

Even in his final prison cell, Paul requested *"the books, but especially the parchments"* (2 Tim 4:13). Like Wheaton student and missionary martyr **Jim Elliott**, believers should pursue the degree **"A.U.G."—Approved Unto God**. Pastor Spivey also challenged the men through the *Titus 10* Bible study initiative.

Holding up a sharp knife from the Menorize team, Pastor Spivey contrasted a **surgeon** with someone hacking with a **machete**. We must move past isolated proof texts to grasp God's redemptive meta-narrative—Old Testament shadows pointing to Christ the Lamb, the Great Commission, and discerning primary essentials from secondary controversies (Col 2:16–17: *"the body is of Christ"*).

### The Singularity of Aim in Biblical Study
- **Making Much of Christ:** Never mere Bible trivia; every study exalts Jesus.
- **Humbling Hearts First:** Bringing repentance, faith, and restoration to our own lives first.
- **Leading to Holiness & Spirit-Filled Living:** All Scripture (2 Tim 3:16–17) equips us for heart holiness and consistent Spirit-produced fruit.
- **Propelling Kingdom Mission:** Compelling believers to spread the gospel.

> **Holiness Word Study — *Orthotomeo* & *Theopneustos*:**  
> **Orthotomeo** ("rightly dividing") means *"to cut straight"* without crooked detours. **Theopneustos** ("given by inspiration of God") means *"God-breathed."* Rightly cut along its redemptive line, Scripture equips us unto every good work.

---

## 8. Role 4 — The Elder as a Servant of Grace (2 Timothy 2:24–25; 4:1–2)

Jesus forbade Gentile-style lording over others (Matt 20:25–28). Even when preaching and rebuking (2 Tim 4:1–2), an elder acts as a humble servant—never a "boss."

| Leadership Dimension | Worldly "Boss" Mentality | Servant of Grace Leadership |
| :--- | :--- | :--- |
| **Source of Authority** | Lords it over people by title, ego, or paycheck control | Humble stewardship under Christ (Matt 20:25–28) |
| **View of the Church** | "My ministry," "my platform," "my reputation" | God's ministry, God's flock, bought with His blood |
| **Response to Opposition** | Quick-tempered, argumentative, defensive, or petty | Gentle, apt to teach, patient, praying for repentance |
| **Handling Sin in the Camp** | Ignores problems out of fear or explodes in anger | Courageously reproves in love so sin does not spread |

Most often, God tells a frustrated leader: *"Pray for them. Be patient with them. Love them."* Yet because *"problems don't age well,"* loving elders must sometimes rebuke sin to **avert** strife and keep the camp pure.

---

## 9. Role 5 — The Elder as a Shepherd of Grace & Finishing Well (2 Timothy 4:6–21)

Paul's closing list—Demas, Luke, restored John Mark (*"profitable to me for the ministry"*), Tychicus, Alexander, Priscilla and Aquila, Onesiphorus, Erastus, and Trophimus—shows that **shepherds know their sheep**. Holding up the 2022 Haven of Rest directory compiled by Sister Carrie, Pastor Spivey mentioned the Atwell family's trials, Mitch and Jeanette near the two-year anniversary of Stephen's passing, and drifted members needing care.

This faithfulness culminates in **2 Timothy 4:6–8**: *"I have fought a good fight, I have finished my course, I have kept the faith"*—with a crown of righteousness promised to **all** who love His appearing. Pastor Spivey pointed to **Preacher Long**, resting in the cemetery yet still speaking (Heb 11:4) through a legacy leaving an **aroma of grace**.

> **Conservative Holiness Legacy:**  
> From Paul to early Methodist class-leaders, campmeeting pioneers, and faithful local pastors like Preacher Long, Pastor Spivey, and Pastor Anthony, God raises up elders who guard pure doctrine, walk in heart holiness, and pass the torch unbroken.

---

## 10. Practical Life Application: Living & Honoring Grace in Leadership Today

- **For Youth and Young Adults:** Practice 1 Timothy 4:12 in your texts, friendships, purity, and attitude at home, and listen for God's call.
- **For Men in the Church:** Join serious Bible study (like Titus 10), seek entire sanctification, and step up into spiritual mentoring and leadership.
- **For Families and Parents:** Build grace-filled marriages and raise respectful children grounded in sound doctrine.
- **For the Whole Congregation:** Pray daily for Pastor Spivey, Pastor Anthony, and future elders; honor godly authority; and use your church directory to care for hurting or absent sheep this week.

> **In Plain English (Your Challenge Before Next Sunday):**  
> Pick one name from your church family or youth group who has been discouraged or missing lately and check on them. Then read a full chapter like Titus 1 or 2 Timothy 2 in context—growing into a specimen, soldier, scholar, servant, and shepherd of grace!

---

## 11. Small Group & Personal Reflection

1. **Transformational Grace (Titus 2:11–14):** How does seeing grace as *foundational, transformational, and motivational* protect us from both prideful legalism and sloppy compromise? Where do you sense the Holy Spirit calling you to deeper heart purity today?
2. **Biblical Church Accountability (Titus 1:5–9):** Why is a team of godly, accountable elders healthier than either a one-man autocracy or a leaderless congregation? How can our church pray for and strengthen Pastor Spivey and Pastor Anthony in their oversight?
3. **Becoming a Living Specimen (1 Timothy 4:12):** Among the six arenas—word, conduct, love, spirit, faith, and purity—which one do people notice most quickly in your daily life, and which one needs intentional consecration right now?
4. **Soldier's Toughness & Mentoring (2 Timothy 2:1–4):** What "civilian entanglements" or petty church squabbles distract believers from fighting the real battle against sin, self, and Satan? Who is one younger believer you can intentionally encourage or mentor this month?
5. **Pursuing the "A.U.G." Degree (2 Timothy 2:15):** Have you been treating Scripture like a quick snack of isolated proof texts, or like a surgeon's precision instrument? What practical habit will help you understand the whole redemptive storyline of the Bible?
6. **Shepherd's Heart & Finishing Well (2 Timothy 4:6–21):** Think of someone in our congregation who is walking through grief or drifting away like Demas, or needing restoration like John Mark. What concrete step of shepherd care can you take this week so that, one day, you too finish your course with an aroma of grace?

---

## 12. Closing Prayer Focus

> **Closing Prayer Focus:** *Heavenly Father, thank You for the transforming grace of Jesus Christ that saves us, purifies our hearts through entire sanctification, and empowers us to live holy in this present world. We lift up Pastor David Spivey, Pastor Anthony, and every man You are raising up at Haven of Rest Bible Church and beyond to serve as biblical elders. Make us living specimens of purity and love, tough soldiers who endure hardness and mentor the next generation, diligent scholars approved unto You, humble servants motivated solely by Your approval, and tender shepherds who know and restore Your sheep. Keep our eyes fixed on Jesus so that when our departure is at hand, we may fight a good fight, finish our course, keep the faith, and leave an unmistakable aroma of grace for Your eternal glory. In Jesus' mighty name, Amen.*